Being reviewed:
Dictatorship across Borders: Brazil, Chile, and the South American Cold War
Amid the spiraling news cycle detailing the disappearances of immigrants in the United States in the summer of 2025, the story of Luis Leon caught my attention. The 82-year-old Chilean refugee, a victim of torture by the civic-military dictatorship in Chile who had been granted political asylum in the United States in 1987, went missing after presenting himself on June 20, 2025, for an interview with US Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS). Leon, a legal permanent resident from Allentown, Pennsylvania, had lost his green card and went to a USCIS office to recover it. However, when he arrived at the office, Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents separated him from his wife and led him away in handcuffs. A few weeks later, his family received news that he had died. Later, through a relative in Chile, they learned that he was alive, and hospitalized, in Guatemala, a country he had never visited.
The day after Leon’s story was picked up by national and international media outlets, the US Department of Homeland Security (DHS) released a statement insisting that ICE had never “arrested or deported” him to Guatemala and denouncing the reports as a hoax. DHS’s statement reminded me of an infamous headline in the Chilean newspaper La Segunda (owned by media mogul and Augusto Pinochet loyalist Agustín Edwards) from February 9, 1977. Published in large red letters, the headline blared, “THERE ARE NO SUCH DISAPPEARED,” at a time when reports from the Vicariate of Solidarity in Chile and Amnesty International consistently indicated the opposite: that the Pinochet regime had disappeared hundreds of people.
The news of Leon’s arrest, disappearance, and expulsion from the very country that had also granted him asylum resonated deeply as I read Mila Burns’s Dictatorship across Borders: Brazil, Chile, and the South American Cold War. This timely study focuses on the diverse experiences of a heterogeneous group of Brazilian exiles in Chile, many of whom endured the horrors of surveillance, persecution, and torture twice: first in Brazil, their country of origin, and then in Chile, the country to which they emigrated. Some 1,200 Brazilian citizens ended up settling in Chile between 1964 and 1972. Burns gives body, memory, and affect to this group of people and organizes their exodus to Chile into three major waves: two during the government of Eduardo Frei Montalva (1964–1970) and one during the short-lived government of Salvador Allende (1970–1973). The first wave, in 1964, was composed mainly of left-wing professors, politicians, artists, and professionals, such as Fernando Henrique Cardoso, Celso Furtado, Paulo Freire, and Vânia Bambirra. All left Brazil after the coup that ousted the democratic government of João Goulart ushered in the civic-military dictatorship and arrived in Chile after Frei (not Freire, a regrettable copyedit mistake on page 26) assumed the Chilean presidency. The second wave of exiles arrived over 1968 and 1969, when the persecution of the Brazilian Armed Forces’ opponents intensified. And the third wave occurred after Allende’s election in 1970, during one of the most critical periods of the Cold War in South America. Burns’s interlocutors belong to these last two waves.
Burns’s book emerges as a valuable tool for fathoming our present predicament.
Through oral history and exhaustive archival work with documents declassified between 2009 and 2014, Burns recounts in unswerving prose how, after the intensification of the civic-military dictatorship in Brazil in 1968, hundreds of Brazilians chose to flee, went into self-exile, or were expelled, as was the notable case of two groups of political prisoners, the “Quarenta” (a group of forty prisoners who, after being released in 1970, fled to Algeria) and the “Setenta” (another group released and expelled to Santiago by plane in 1971).
After the overthrow of Allende on September 11, 1973, at least 123 Brazilian citizens were arrested in Chile. 88 were tortured inside the National Stadium, and at least six were killed by the Pinochet regime, one inside the flagship Chilean soccer arena turned concentration camp. (Burns takes these figures from a 1974 Amnesty International report, updated by the Brazilian Truth Commission in 2012, and shares them with the caveat that they are never definitive.)
Burns’s book begins “Before Allende” (the title of chapter 1), with the long decade of the 1960s, and offers a brief overview of the governments that preceded Goulart’s (1961–1964). This long view allows Burns to inform an Anglophone audience about lesser-known moments and events in the regional Cold War. In its best moments, the narrative reads like a detective thriller about spies and double agents, secret meetings, telegrams, and letters with coded messages. For example, chapter 3 delves into the remarkable cast of this murderous and macabre intrigue. One key player was CIEX, the Brazilian intelligence agency founded in 1966. After 1968, when preventing Allende’s election in Chile became one of Brazil’s objectives, CIEX opened an office in Santiago and exported dozens of spies to the Chilean capital. Burns meticulously describes the paranoia Brazilian exiles experienced in Chile, and the sense of persecution, along with a marked climate of xenophobia, that became a reality after the 1973 coup.1
The narrative is punctuated by the testimonies of “exiles, torturers, business people and other actors.” A particularly moving account comes from Otto Brockes. Through Brockes, we learn of the complicity and negligence of both the Chilean and Brazilian governments in the death of Wânio José de Mattos, the only Brazilian confirmed to have died inside the National Stadium. De Mattos, a militant of Popular Revolutionary Vanguard (VPR), was arrested along with his wife, Maria das Dores, and his daughter Roberta. Once inside the stadium, he was separated from them. (This family separation thing sounds familiar, doesn’t it?) Brockes, a physician who was detained alongside him, recounts that de Mattos suffered tremendously, both emotionally, because of the separation from his family, and physically due to “chronic constipation because of a lack of liquid and fiber ingestion.” Brockes tells Burns that he tried unsuccessfully to advocate for de Mattos and that, days after officials removed de Mattos for surgery, Brockes and others were told that he had not survived.
De Mattos’s family spent two decades trying to find out what happened to him. Only with the publication of the Rettig report in 1992 was his family able to obtain confirmation of his death (cause: peritonitis). Yet, as Burns recounts, the Brazilian Ministry of Foreign Affairs had confirmation of his death, which occurred on October 16, 1973, in a report dated December 31, 1973, but decided to keep this information secret. Testimonies from “minor” witnesses like Brockes emphasize something that the Brazilian exiles who survived this harrowing period knew and felt: once in Chile, they continued to be spied and reported on by double agents from their own country. “[F]or the exiles,” Burns explains, “this constant surveillance was the first indication that the Brazilian authoritarian regime was cooperating with Chilean and right-wing groups who planned to overthrow the democratically elected socialist president” Allende.
A strength of the second chapter, truly the heart of the book, is that it does not homogenize the experiences of exile but rather describes and analyzes them in their differences and specificities. In Chile, the Brazilian exiles continued to work, study, and as several militants and ex-guerrillas recount, deepen the socialist revolutionary struggle. Like their Chilean counterparts, some advocated for a socialist utopia through democratic means, others through guerrilla warfare. Refusing to acknowledge that it had “expelled them,” the Brazilian government did not call these exiles exiliados but asilados (asylees), a label that implied “that the group enjoyed legal protection and support from the Chilean government,” a reminder of authoritarian and fascist governments’ propensity for doublespeak.
Dictatorship across Borders does more than simply reframe the experiences of exiles. By adopting a transnational perspective, and expanding the significant insights already made by Brazilian journalist Roberto Simon, whose groundbreaking book O Brasil contra a democracia: a dictadura, o golpe no Chile, e a Guerra Fria na América do Soul (2021) is mentioned in a footnote, Burns demonstrates that the Brazilian civic-military dictatorship (1964–1985), a regime that includes part of the diplomatic class and the business elite, or what Burns calls “the organic elites,” conspired from the beginning of the 1960s with its Chilean counterpart, first to prevent Allende’s election, and then to overthrow him. This hypothesis, Burns indicates, is not new; the first revelations about the “Brazil Connection” were made by former US ambassador to Chile, Nathaniel Davis, in 1985. Likewise, in South America, there is considerable clarity (along with numerous studies) regarding the instrumental role played by business elites (who also controlled the media) in Brazil’s and Chile’s coups.
What is new, however, is an examination of the mobility of Chilean businesspeople who settled in Brazil after Allende’s election. Once there, Chilean entrepreneurs connected with “architects of the Brazilian 1964 coup.” To study the role of capital and corporate elites transnationally, Burns centers Brazilian think tanks, such as the Institute for Social Studies and Research and the Institute for Democratic Action, and highlights how both influenced members of the Federation of Chilean Industry and the Chilean far-right paramilitary organization Frente Nacionalista Patria y Libertad.
A separate resource that scholars of the Latin American Cold War have at our disposal today, which we did not have in the 1980s and ’90s, are hundreds of declassified, albeit heavily redacted, documents. Burns makes excellent use of many of these documents, although I was surprised not to see any mention of the Latin American Transnational Surveillance Dataset. There are also the testimonies cited throughout the book, the result of Burns’s remarkable oral history research. These testimonies support the undeniable facts that the Brazilian government surveilled, persecuted, and prevented its own citizens from seeking asylum at its own embassy after the coup in Chile on September 11, 1973, leading to their kidnapping, torture, and, in some cases, murder; also, that the dictatorial regime and the organic elites of Brazil (like the organic elites of Chile) attempted to prevent the rise of the socialists and the spread of Marxism at all costs and by any means necessary.
In addition to offering a gripping analysis of declassified archives concerning the Cold War in South America, Dictatorship across Borders centers testimonies and oral history that shed light on the reach and sophistication of the surveillance apparatus devised by the Brazilian state to monitor and oppress its own leftist population both at home and abroad, as well as on the key role that diplomacy, corporations, and economic elites from both Brazil and Chile had in the long-planned overthrow of Allende’s Popular Unity government in 1973. In the current conjuncture, marked by the rise of fascism, the return of far-right regimes in América, and ubiquitous surveillance, Burns’s book emerges as a valuable tool for fathoming our present predicament and the unexpected and reluctant roles so-called minor characters, like Luis Leon, play in it.
This article was commissioned by Catherine S. Ramírez.
- Regarding xenophobia, this leaflet from 1974 is telling (and its rhetoric sounds uncannily familiar): “The actions carried out by the armed forces and police only pursue the good of Chile and Chileans, and therefore they have the support of civilians. No compassion will exist for the foreign extremists who have come to kill Chileans. Citizen: remain alert to find them and denounce them to the nearest military authority” (quoted in Burns 129; emphasis added). ↩











